1. Pepperoni Grill: Located near Middleton Park, Pepperoni Grill is both a traditional pizza joint that serves whole pies, slices, sandwiches, and salads all day, every day. A traditional ‘New York Style’ oversized slice is perfect for lunch on the go or a mid-day snack. Order online or walk right in, the folks at Pepperoni Grill will make you feel welcome and make sure you leave happy and full!

Scott’s Pick: An Italian Stallion hero, extra toasty

2. Bobs Dogs Oak Island. Who doesn’t love a classic hotdog. Bob’s dogs has been serving locals and visitors alike for over 35 years. With fun takes on the classic dog, such as the Oak Island Dog or Parrot Dog, you’ll find whatever your heart desires here. Not a fan of hot dogs? No worries – they also have a selection of burgers and sandwiches. Stop by today and say hi!

Scott’s Pick: Cheese Dog in Paradise

3. Kai Joes Taco Stand: Centrally located with online ordering – Kai Joes is built to deliver good food, fast. You can’t beat any of their classic tacos and burritos, but don’t sleep on their unique beach snacks – perfect handhelds to take with you to the sand.

Scott’s Pick: Mel’s Firecracker Nachos and Buffalo Cauliflower Bites

4. Oak Island Sub Shop: Another local and tourist favorite, Oak Island Sub Shop is your answer for the best classic deli sandwich on the island. West Virginia natives opened this spot in 2004 and have been serving up HUGE sandwiches ever since. Order online or stop in and dine.

Scott’s Pick: Tie: The Muffuletta or Turkey Bacon Ranch

5. Bar-B-Que House: Quality, consistency, and Southern Hospitality are the name of the game here. Bar-B-Que House is perfect for parties of all sizes, serving sandwiches for one or catering to a party of 100+. The bbq is classic and perfect, but the desserts are game changers – home made and always delicious.

Scott’s Pick: A bowl of Brunswick Stew, a BBQ sandwich, and Banana Pudding